ECDSA 公開鍵の復元：リカバリ ID、v、ecrecover

def recover(e: int, r: int, s: int, recid: int):
    """Return the public key Q with s = k^-1 (e + r*d), or None if recid does not name a curve point."""
    if not (0 < r < n and 0 < s < n):
        raise ValueError("r and s must be in [1, n-1]")
    x = r + (recid >> 1) * n          # recid 2 and 3: R.x was >= n and got reduced
    if x >= p:
        return None
    alpha = (x * x * x + 7) % p
    y = pow(alpha, (p + 1) // 4, p)   # p % 4 == 3, so this is a square root if one exists
    if y * y % p != alpha:
        return None                   # r is not the x-coordinate of any point
    if y & 1 != recid & 1:
        y = p - y                     # recid bit 0 is the parity of R.y
    R = (x, y)
    r_inv = pow(r, -1, n)
    return add(mul(s * r_inv % n, R), mul(-e * r_inv % n, G))   # Q = r^-1 (sR - eG)


def eth_address(Q):
    k = keccak.new(digest_bits=256, data=Q[0].to_bytes(32, "big") + Q[1].to_bytes(32, "big"))
    return "0x" + k.hexdigest()[-40:]


def eth_personal_digest(message: bytes) -> int:
    data = b"\x19Ethereum Signed Message:\n" + str(len(message)).encode() + message
    return int.from_bytes(keccak.new(digest_bits=256, data=data).digest(), "big")

KEY=$(cast wallet new --json | python3 -c "import json,sys; print(json.load(sys.stdin)['data'][0]['private_key'])")
ADDR=$(cast wallet address --private-key "$KEY")
SIG=$(cast wallet sign --private-key "$KEY" "hello from ecdsa.com")
cast wallet verify --address "$ADDR" "hello from ecdsa.com" "$SIG"
python3 eth_recover.py "hello from ecdsa.com" "$SIG" "$ADDR"

address: 0x22baE48F42D493eDcF82ddB7e47480B7233917b3
signature: 0x150e0d6f3cc85f603300fe1801bc4397021a51495c53186f15ecb05f9e57dcbe2a17a5521f6c42792fc22a98754e5c01dd26ac42009e8d24d3cb713a8fe96fed1c
Validation succeeded. Address 0x22baE48F42D493eDcF82ddB7e47480B7233917b3 signed this message.
r=0x150e0d6f3cc85f603300fe1801bc4397021a51495c53186f15ecb05f9e57dcbe
s=0x2a17a5521f6c42792fc22a98754e5c01dd26ac42009e8d24d3cb713a8fe96fed
v=28  (s is low)
recid 0: 0xb1775d58a680572a45fe5d6ba094c56b0b748c9d
recid 1: 0x22bae48f42d493edcf82ddb7e47480b7233917b3  <- v - 27
recid 2: no point (x = r + n is not below p)
recid 3: no point (x = r + n is not below p)
matches the signer: True
same signature, other message -> 0x994ba1aaf9e6b96710727d919140aff23f56407c

as signed (v, r, s)                0x00000000000000000000000022bae48f42d493edcf82ddb7e47480b7233917b3
twin (55-v, r, n-s)                0x00000000000000000000000022bae48f42d493edcf82ddb7e47480b7233917b3
v = 29                             0x
s + 1                              0x000000000000000000000000412fbd6e833de18577db8f41022c54e852192b34
s = 0                              0x

for (const [label, sig] of [
  ["65-byte", signature],
  ["64-byte compact", compact],
  ["63 bytes", signature.slice(0, -4)],
  ["v = 29", signature.slice(0, -2) + "1d"],
]) {
  try {
    const who = await recoverMessageAddress({ message, signature: sig });
    console.log(`recover ${label.padEnd(16)} ${who === account.address ? "signer" : who}`);
  } catch (e) {
    console.log(`recover ${label.padEnd(16)} ${e.shortMessage ?? e.message.split("\n")[0]}`);
  }
}

// The same recovery with noble: the recovery bit travels separately from the 64-byte (r, s).
const digest = hashMessage(message, "bytes");
const rs = Buffer.from(signature.slice(2, 130), "hex");
const pub = secp256k1.Signature.fromBytes(rs, "compact").addRecoveryBit(parsed.yParity).recoverPublicKey(digest);
console.log(`noble recovers    ${pub.toHex(true)} (compressed public key)`);

signer            0xa9650f6049917850af00B8e7Ffc386d9A3e18C08
signature         65 bytes, v=27, yParity=0
EIP-2098 compact  64 bytes, top bit of byte 32 = yParity: true
recover 65-byte          signer
recover 64-byte compact  invalid signature length
recover 63 bytes         invalid signature length
recover v = 29           Invalid yParityOrV value
noble recovers    036a079737b9587224344944600570a311f21b3b06f5c920b24bcd95e993afd7e0 (compressed public key)
legacy tx, chain 1: v=38 (yParity 1)
EIP-1559 tx, chain 1: v=28, yParity=1

SIG=$($CLI signmessagewithprivkey "$WIF" "$MSG")
$CLI verifymessage "$ADDR" "$SIG" "$MSG"
python3 btc_recover.py "$MSG" "$SIG"      # recover by hand, then build three variants

address: mvzrMJdGFmYPJw79zHz5i2WqMHdwchtbr1
signature: H6uRgJJnTugkk5XeUQl+eE1oY5/L6yZZORJHwTn1ohJdFOWEPPUvL6oHzDx2lAeoI+l1d3ipt5sw3TmF/tkpz60=
verifymessage: true
65 bytes: header 31 -> recid 0, compressed key: True, s is low
recovered public key: 03b7b74bd1e7c935c284dbb71b48649f1ff6a5cb939d615061204271a61f4232e1
its regtest P2PKH address: mvzrMJdGFmYPJw79zHz5i2WqMHdwchtbr1
other recid (header 32)              verifymessage: false
uncompressed header (27)             verifymessage: false
high-S twin (header 32, n - s)       verifymessage: true

"""Turn a DER ECDSA signature without a recovery id (what HSMs and cloud KMS return) into an Ethereum signature."""
import sys

from cryptography.hazmat.primitives import hashes
from cryptography.hazmat.primitives.asymmetric import ec
from cryptography.hazmat.primitives.asymmetric.utils import Prehashed, decode_dss_signature

from recover import eth_address, eth_personal_digest, n, recover

# Stand-in for the HSM: a secp256k1 key that signs a 32-byte digest and returns DER, nothing else.
hsm_key = ec.generate_private_key(ec.SECP256K1())
public = hsm_key.public_key().public_numbers()
expected = eth_address((public.x, public.y))     # what you would derive once from GetPublicKey


def hsm_sign_digest(digest: bytes) -> bytes:
    return hsm_key.sign(digest, ec.ECDSA(Prehashed(hashes.SHA256())))   # any 32-byte digest


message = sys.argv[1].encode()
e = eth_personal_digest(message)
der = hsm_sign_digest(e.to_bytes(32, "big"))
r, s = decode_dss_signature(der)
print(f"DER signature: {len(der)} bytes, s is {'high' if s > n // 2 else 'low'}")
if s > n // 2:
    s = n - s                                     # EIP-2: transactions need low-S; normalize everything
for recid in (0, 1):                              # find the parity that recovers our own key
    Q = recover(e, r, s, recid)
    if Q and eth_address(Q) == expected:
        break
else:
    raise SystemExit("neither recovery id matches the key")
sig = r.to_bytes(32, "big") + s.to_bytes(32, "big") + bytes([27 + recid])
print(f"address {expected}\nrecid {recid}\nsignature 0x{sig.hex()}")

DER signature: 71 bytes, s is high
address 0x3bf48296556c8b52217d22066c7239c50f2102e6
recid 1
signature 0x052fbd197e707e99a4c38648b4a65fb674b15c93025878c55b3950f876bb5cf634aa76d1ffe274696a3d94ba225ae72ab73af4292a0681dc7262dc8ef9495d071c
Validation succeeded. Address 0x3bf48296556c8B52217D22066C7239C50F2102E6 signed this message.